プライム無料体験をお試しいただけます
プライム無料体験で、この注文から無料配送特典をご利用いただけます。
非会員 | プライム会員 | |
---|---|---|
通常配送 | ¥410 - ¥450* | 無料 |
お急ぎ便 | ¥510 - ¥550 | |
お届け日時指定便 | ¥510 - ¥650 |
*Amazon.co.jp発送商品の注文額 ¥3,500以上は非会員も無料
無料体験はいつでもキャンセルできます。30日のプライム無料体験をぜひお試しください。
ショスタコーヴィチ交響曲第10番 テミルカーノフ&ヴェルビエ音楽祭管弦楽団 [DVD]
形式: DVD
¥3,988 ¥3,988 税込
{"desktop_buybox_group_1":[{"displayPrice":"¥3,988","priceAmount":3988.00,"currencySymbol":"¥","integerValue":"3,988","decimalSeparator":null,"fractionalValue":null,"symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"CmSCIukjLCnpUsiy5o2OpiZFfkioALkpAqRCbtBjY7qHDo4VTtGqUkMOUZuFAaTCvpio5SA%2BWI5ob4a4N7qVKmQLqZgr9fun0oeBnw4%2BFiESAKqVT%2FGwGdgRbDRCMWHz52xsFc7pvvQ7mwt9qJ0X7JBT9MUJHRamdaHr4fOPwdom%2BN78YQt%2BwA%3D%3D","locale":"ja-JP","buyingOptionType":"NEW","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":0}]}
購入オプションとあわせ買い
Amazon 新生活SALE (Final) 開催中
期間限定!人気商品がお買い得。最大5,000ポイント還元ポイントアップキャンペーン
Amazon 新生活SALE (Final) を今すぐチェック
Amazon 新生活SALE (Final) を今すぐチェック
商品の説明
ヴァルビエ音楽祭だから実現できる巨匠と若手の饗宴! テミルカーノフの切れ味抜群のショスタコーヴィチ交響曲第10番。 毎夏恒例のスイスのスキー・リゾートで開催されるヴェルビエ音楽祭。1993年に始まって以来、世界中から音楽ファン、一流アーティスト、若手アーティストが集まり質の高い演奏を繰り広げています。ヴェルビエ・フェスティヴァル・オーケストラは優秀な若手演奏家からなるオーケストラ。今回その才気溢れるオケを率いるのは巨匠ユーリ・テミルカーノフ。テミルカーノフはムラヴィンスキーからレニングラード・フィル(現サンクト・ペテルブルク・フィル)を引き継ぎ、新時代を切り開いた名匠。 演目はテミルカーノフお得意のショスタコーヴィチ:交響曲第10番。この曲は1973年の旧レニングラード・フィルとのライヴ録音以来36年ぶり。抜群の切れ味と緊迫感、臨時編成のオケとは思えないテミルカーノフの統率力に脱帽です。(キングインターナショナル)
登録情報
- アスペクト比 : 1.78:1
- メーカーにより製造中止になりました : いいえ
- 言語 : 英語
- 梱包サイズ : 18.9 x 13.6 x 1.6 cm; 113.4 g
- EAN : 0880242791382
- 製造元リファレンス : MFR880242791382#N
- メディア形式 : クラシック
- 発売日 : 2010/8/30
- 出演 : Verbier Fo, Temirkanov
- 販売元 : Euroarts
- ASIN : B003OT6I3C
- ディスク枚数 : 1
- Amazon 売れ筋ランキング: - 315,054位DVD (DVDの売れ筋ランキングを見る)
- - 1,084位フェスティバル
- - 1,803位交響曲・管弦楽曲DVD
- カスタマーレビュー:
-
トップレビュー
上位レビュー、対象国: 日本
レビューのフィルタリング中に問題が発生しました。後でもう一度試してください。
2012年11月4日に日本でレビュー済み
Amazonで購入
本盤は非常に力任せで血気盛んな演奏。またテミルカーノフの指揮は若手にわかりずらい為、随所にミスや事故が散見される。まるでソ連のユースオケを聴いている様で、どうしてもテミルカーノフ/サンクトペテルブルグフィルで聴いてみたいと思わせる。 よって、フェドセーエフ、カラヤン、ムラヴィンスキー、ヤンソンス等の演奏を知っている僕としては他人にオススメは出来ないDVDと言える。
2005年1月31日に日本でレビュー済み
Amazonで購入
ショスタコーヴィチのDVDはなかなかないので張り切って見てみましたが、いやはやなんとも。
普段日本やドイツのオーケストラの実に丁寧な演奏を聞き慣れているせいか、
ロシアのオーケストラならではの大味な演奏に驚き、また新鮮に感じました。
先ず度肝を抜かれたのは第一楽章の開始。
重苦しく始まるものと思っていたのですが、滑るように軽やかに流していました。
それから、やりたい放題のトランペットに、ソロをちゃんと吹かないクラリネットとホルン。
第一ヴァイオリンのアンサンブルもアヤシイものです。
これが本場のショスタコなのでしょうか。
きちんとした演奏を望まれる場合はお薦めしませんが、これはこれで面白いと思います。
映像はまずまずでしたし。
アンコールも4曲収録されていて、その中のグラズノフの作品が一番いい演奏だったような気がします。
普段日本やドイツのオーケストラの実に丁寧な演奏を聞き慣れているせいか、
ロシアのオーケストラならではの大味な演奏に驚き、また新鮮に感じました。
先ず度肝を抜かれたのは第一楽章の開始。
重苦しく始まるものと思っていたのですが、滑るように軽やかに流していました。
それから、やりたい放題のトランペットに、ソロをちゃんと吹かないクラリネットとホルン。
第一ヴァイオリンのアンサンブルもアヤシイものです。
これが本場のショスタコなのでしょうか。
きちんとした演奏を望まれる場合はお薦めしませんが、これはこれで面白いと思います。
映像はまずまずでしたし。
アンコールも4曲収録されていて、その中のグラズノフの作品が一番いい演奏だったような気がします。
他の国からのトップレビュー

Pitou 1777
5つ星のうち4.0
Autre témoignage d’un grand chef récemment disparu
2023年11月28日にフランスでレビュー済みAmazonで購入
Ce n’est pas ma symphonie préférée d’un compositeur qui n’est pas non plus mon préféré. Et pourtant, voir ce vieux chef diriger ces jeunes artistes de l’orchestre du Festival de Verbier est émouvant : transmission d’un savoir, de la tradition russe, dans une œuvre à l’orchestration riche. Quelle tendresse de sa part ! Quant à l’œuvre, le premier mouvement dure près d’une demi-heure, soit la moitié de l’œuvre. Plusieurs thèmes s’entremêlent, de façon pas très claire pour un non initié. Je lis que le deuxième, allegro, serait une caricature de Staline, bon, je veux bien, je ne l’ai pas connu. Les deux derniers mouvements me sont plus accessibles.
Commentaires en anglais, allemand, français.
Commentaires en anglais, allemand, français.

Casey Roo
5つ星のうち5.0
Unforgettable - not just the music, but the whole performance. Please buy; you'll be moved and amazed
2017年12月27日に英国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
There's a heart-stopping moment at the end of the second movement that's haunting me.
Let's begin by saying that this is a superlative performance by anyone's standards. It's also a superlative DVD production, with the camera taking in the individual players, pairs of players, and the conductor .... leave it there for the moment ...
If you don't know the back story: this is the first symphony Shostakovich published after the death of Stalin; he'd had to keep quiet for five years. The first movement is a beautiful meditation, deeply felt; the third and fourth movements are a triumphant celebration of the individual soul, Shostakovich quoting his own musical motif based on his name. The second movement is an expression of pure rage. Crescendo follows crescendo; energy pulses out from all the players; he is so, so angry that Stalin ever existed.
Here's the magic moment: at the end of the second movement the conductor casts a strong, comforting eye at the players, one by one; then he wipes away his tears; and then he uses both hands to compose his face into a smile, and begins the third movement. It's extraordinary.
Let's begin by saying that this is a superlative performance by anyone's standards. It's also a superlative DVD production, with the camera taking in the individual players, pairs of players, and the conductor .... leave it there for the moment ...
If you don't know the back story: this is the first symphony Shostakovich published after the death of Stalin; he'd had to keep quiet for five years. The first movement is a beautiful meditation, deeply felt; the third and fourth movements are a triumphant celebration of the individual soul, Shostakovich quoting his own musical motif based on his name. The second movement is an expression of pure rage. Crescendo follows crescendo; energy pulses out from all the players; he is so, so angry that Stalin ever existed.
Here's the magic moment: at the end of the second movement the conductor casts a strong, comforting eye at the players, one by one; then he wipes away his tears; and then he uses both hands to compose his face into a smile, and begins the third movement. It's extraordinary.

Thomas Schnackenburg
5つ星のうち5.0
Schostakowitsch: 8. Sinfonie
2014年3月28日にドイツでレビュー済みAmazonで購入
eine wundervolle Aufnahme, sowohl was die Orchesterleistung angeht wie auch das Dirigat. Mir war der Dirigent nicht bekannt: jetzt kenne ich ihn!

DAVID A. FLETCHER
5つ星のうち5.0
Shostakovich, Kogan, and an amazing concert....
2004年2月13日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
I'll be brief. If you're a "Shostakolic", add this to your roster of favorite Symphony #10's. Even if your interest is mainly in collecting bravura performances of key Russian works as played by Russian orchestras, then by all means snatch this up. Visuals are quite good, the sound is terrific, and most importantly, the Moscow State Symphony Orchestra under the baton of Music Director Pavel Kogan (yes, son of violinist Leonid Kogan), are caught in a moment of white heat and intensity.
Important "extras" for the DVD include the optional musical analysis subtitles, which can enhance the viewing experience for both the seasoned listener as well as those who are coming to the music as Shostakovich neophytes. There's some debate as to an implied or overt "program" to the 10th, and it's safe to say that both Kogan and his forces, as well as the DVD producers, come down squarely on the Volkov/"Testimony" side of performance practice. In their hands, the symphonic journey of Dmitri Shostakovich, composer, living and writing under the thumb of Stalin for decades--and--suriving to both tell the tale and celebrate the triumph of the artist over tyranny, is all too clear. Even without the analysis subtitles, simply following maestro Kogan's energetic conducting provides ample visual "evidence" of this; there's more than a bit of Bernstein and von Karajan in the way his expressions urge the musical events forward.
If there's any complaint to be found with the performance from a technical standpoint, it may be centered on some specious intonation in the winds, apparently centered--oddly--on the first oboe. The "shrieking" sequence in the 2nd movement--where the oboes and flutes play unison--is perhaps the worst example, though to be fair, it IS one of the most difficult wind passages in the literature to get spot-on, with all parties playing in the upper range and at double-ff volume.
On the other side of the balance sheet, you'll hear WONDERFUL sectional string work, characteristicly braying Russian brass (love it or hate it, it's there!), and assured, inspired leadership over the procedings by Kogan. At 73 minutes, it's apparent that this performance was most likely the second half of a longer concert, perhaps beginning with a short opener and a concerto. In addtion to the Shostakovich, we're treated to four (!) encores, including the Glazunov "Entr'acte from Raymonda", the Tchaikovsky "Waltz from Eugene Onegin," Wagner's "Prelude to the third act of Lohengrin," and finally the gloriously galumphing "Parody" from one of Shostakovich's ballet suites. Throughout, the audience is enthusiastic and reasonably quiet when need be, with coughing and shuffling held to a minimum.
The concert, dating from 1990, derives from Kogan's first tour abroad with "his" orchestra. The Berlin Wall had fallen only a few years prior, and the great post-Communist opening to the West had truly begun. The sense of occasion is obviously shared by audience and orchestra alike, and the pride with which the Moscow State Symphony Orchestra deliver perhaps the greatest symphony by Russia's most important 20th century composer is well-earned.
Important "extras" for the DVD include the optional musical analysis subtitles, which can enhance the viewing experience for both the seasoned listener as well as those who are coming to the music as Shostakovich neophytes. There's some debate as to an implied or overt "program" to the 10th, and it's safe to say that both Kogan and his forces, as well as the DVD producers, come down squarely on the Volkov/"Testimony" side of performance practice. In their hands, the symphonic journey of Dmitri Shostakovich, composer, living and writing under the thumb of Stalin for decades--and--suriving to both tell the tale and celebrate the triumph of the artist over tyranny, is all too clear. Even without the analysis subtitles, simply following maestro Kogan's energetic conducting provides ample visual "evidence" of this; there's more than a bit of Bernstein and von Karajan in the way his expressions urge the musical events forward.
If there's any complaint to be found with the performance from a technical standpoint, it may be centered on some specious intonation in the winds, apparently centered--oddly--on the first oboe. The "shrieking" sequence in the 2nd movement--where the oboes and flutes play unison--is perhaps the worst example, though to be fair, it IS one of the most difficult wind passages in the literature to get spot-on, with all parties playing in the upper range and at double-ff volume.
On the other side of the balance sheet, you'll hear WONDERFUL sectional string work, characteristicly braying Russian brass (love it or hate it, it's there!), and assured, inspired leadership over the procedings by Kogan. At 73 minutes, it's apparent that this performance was most likely the second half of a longer concert, perhaps beginning with a short opener and a concerto. In addtion to the Shostakovich, we're treated to four (!) encores, including the Glazunov "Entr'acte from Raymonda", the Tchaikovsky "Waltz from Eugene Onegin," Wagner's "Prelude to the third act of Lohengrin," and finally the gloriously galumphing "Parody" from one of Shostakovich's ballet suites. Throughout, the audience is enthusiastic and reasonably quiet when need be, with coughing and shuffling held to a minimum.
The concert, dating from 1990, derives from Kogan's first tour abroad with "his" orchestra. The Berlin Wall had fallen only a few years prior, and the great post-Communist opening to the West had truly begun. The sense of occasion is obviously shared by audience and orchestra alike, and the pride with which the Moscow State Symphony Orchestra deliver perhaps the greatest symphony by Russia's most important 20th century composer is well-earned.

Jeff Wolf
5つ星のうち2.0
You want fries with that adrenalin?
2014年10月22日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
In his CD set of Lohengrin with the Vienna Philharmonic, Claudio Abbado paces Act III's famous prelude at 3:22. Pavel Kogan and the Moscow State Symphony Orchestra -- in one of their encores following the Shostakovich Symphony No. 10 -- charge through it in two and a half minutes, and the Munich audience goes wild, suspecting a new land speed record has just been set.
It's quite an adrenalin rush, a good circus trick. But at that speed, it's impossible to articulate the music cleanly. Unfortunately, the Shostakovich Tenth is executed in similar fashion.
Kogan & Co.'s first movement clocks in at well under 21 minutes. At 22 minutes in a 1976 concert Symphony No.10 , Mravinsky is faster than the score. Observing Shostakovich's carefully graded tempo shifts -- reasonably but not pedantically -- produces a time of around 24-26 minutes. Kogan's headlong charge demolishes the Moderato movement's architecture, which begins in a dark study, moves to a climax of holy terror as the screws are tightened, then sinks back into isolation and despair. What Kogan churns out, instead, is more muddle than music.
The 1990 audio quality doesn't help. The orchestra's tone is abrasive. Tuttis are nothing but congested noise. Microphones pick up an abundance of audience participation. You'd think a choir of pneumonia patients is included in the orchestration. As for the DVD's purported 5.1 surround sound, forget it.
One potentially valuable feature of this DVD is an optional on-screen music analysis in subtitles. The information provided, though, is superficial, inadequate, or incorrect. For example, subtitles for the first movement say the solo clarinet plays (at 2:04), "the first true theme of the symphony, a direct quotation from Mahler's second symphony, where it is sung to the text: 'Man lies in direst need! Man lies in greatest pain!' Shostakovich admitted that the symphony is a musical portrait of Stalin."
Well, maybe, sort of, and no. Echoes of Mahler occur throughout Shostakovich's music, to be sure. The specific reference is to the Mahler Second's fourth movement, "Urlicht," and the clarinet solo bears a resemblance to the contour of notes toward the end of each of those two lines. A direct quotation? Perhaps, but fleeting and not clearly specified in the "music analysis."
Shostakovich never said, however, that the symphony (first performed in December 1953 after Stalin's death in March of that year) "is a musical portrait of Stalin." Good grief. Neither did the composer claim, as the subtitles assert during the group coughing fit after the end of the first movement, that "the second movement, Allegro, is the supposed Stalin portrait." What Shostakovich is quoted in "Testimony" as saying is that the Scherzo "is a musical portrait of Stalin, roughly speaking. Of course, there are many other things in it" (p. 141). Context usually helps.
Kogan's second movement also outraces Mravinsky's. But the Moscow State Symphony Orchestra is hardly Mravinsky's razor-honed Leningrad Philharmonic, and the playing is often only an approximation of the music. Here and throughout the symphony, orchestral technique suffers. I'd love to have a dollar for every wrong note. Intonation is unreliable. Ensemble work is shabby. Sometimes, you can't hear the trumpets because their bells are pointed into the music stands. At other times, their strident tone blares out above the entire orchestra.
For those who don't read music, the subtitles for the third movement -- where Shostakovich's musical signature appears -- could be especially helpful. But the subtitles pass over repeated occurrences of the DSCH theme (sounded clearly by piccolo, flute, and oboe at 1:09, for example), until at the end of the movement, the analysis finally informs us, "Piccolo and flute have the last word. The four notes, repeated three times, are a musical anagram for Shostakovich's initials. Stalin is gone! Shostakovich survives!" There's no explanation that DSCH stands for the composer's initials in German transliteration (D-mitri Sch-ostakowitsch) or that the notes are the pitches D, E-flat, C, and B-flat (E-flat is "S" in German; B-flat is "H").
Adding to those unseemly exclamations, the subtitles in the Finale are even more banal: "Tension builds to a great climax... Shostakovich's initials -- full orchestra. Draw your own conclusions!!" As the horns in unison ring out DSCH at the end: "The initials again, over and over. Have you gotten the point?" Yes, I think we have.
If this DVD were under $10, it might be worth considering as a curiosity. For $40 or $50 -- or $250? Only if you're in bad need of an adrenalin fix.
It's quite an adrenalin rush, a good circus trick. But at that speed, it's impossible to articulate the music cleanly. Unfortunately, the Shostakovich Tenth is executed in similar fashion.
Kogan & Co.'s first movement clocks in at well under 21 minutes. At 22 minutes in a 1976 concert Symphony No.10 , Mravinsky is faster than the score. Observing Shostakovich's carefully graded tempo shifts -- reasonably but not pedantically -- produces a time of around 24-26 minutes. Kogan's headlong charge demolishes the Moderato movement's architecture, which begins in a dark study, moves to a climax of holy terror as the screws are tightened, then sinks back into isolation and despair. What Kogan churns out, instead, is more muddle than music.
The 1990 audio quality doesn't help. The orchestra's tone is abrasive. Tuttis are nothing but congested noise. Microphones pick up an abundance of audience participation. You'd think a choir of pneumonia patients is included in the orchestration. As for the DVD's purported 5.1 surround sound, forget it.
One potentially valuable feature of this DVD is an optional on-screen music analysis in subtitles. The information provided, though, is superficial, inadequate, or incorrect. For example, subtitles for the first movement say the solo clarinet plays (at 2:04), "the first true theme of the symphony, a direct quotation from Mahler's second symphony, where it is sung to the text: 'Man lies in direst need! Man lies in greatest pain!' Shostakovich admitted that the symphony is a musical portrait of Stalin."
Well, maybe, sort of, and no. Echoes of Mahler occur throughout Shostakovich's music, to be sure. The specific reference is to the Mahler Second's fourth movement, "Urlicht," and the clarinet solo bears a resemblance to the contour of notes toward the end of each of those two lines. A direct quotation? Perhaps, but fleeting and not clearly specified in the "music analysis."
Shostakovich never said, however, that the symphony (first performed in December 1953 after Stalin's death in March of that year) "is a musical portrait of Stalin." Good grief. Neither did the composer claim, as the subtitles assert during the group coughing fit after the end of the first movement, that "the second movement, Allegro, is the supposed Stalin portrait." What Shostakovich is quoted in "Testimony" as saying is that the Scherzo "is a musical portrait of Stalin, roughly speaking. Of course, there are many other things in it" (p. 141). Context usually helps.
Kogan's second movement also outraces Mravinsky's. But the Moscow State Symphony Orchestra is hardly Mravinsky's razor-honed Leningrad Philharmonic, and the playing is often only an approximation of the music. Here and throughout the symphony, orchestral technique suffers. I'd love to have a dollar for every wrong note. Intonation is unreliable. Ensemble work is shabby. Sometimes, you can't hear the trumpets because their bells are pointed into the music stands. At other times, their strident tone blares out above the entire orchestra.
For those who don't read music, the subtitles for the third movement -- where Shostakovich's musical signature appears -- could be especially helpful. But the subtitles pass over repeated occurrences of the DSCH theme (sounded clearly by piccolo, flute, and oboe at 1:09, for example), until at the end of the movement, the analysis finally informs us, "Piccolo and flute have the last word. The four notes, repeated three times, are a musical anagram for Shostakovich's initials. Stalin is gone! Shostakovich survives!" There's no explanation that DSCH stands for the composer's initials in German transliteration (D-mitri Sch-ostakowitsch) or that the notes are the pitches D, E-flat, C, and B-flat (E-flat is "S" in German; B-flat is "H").
Adding to those unseemly exclamations, the subtitles in the Finale are even more banal: "Tension builds to a great climax... Shostakovich's initials -- full orchestra. Draw your own conclusions!!" As the horns in unison ring out DSCH at the end: "The initials again, over and over. Have you gotten the point?" Yes, I think we have.
If this DVD were under $10, it might be worth considering as a curiosity. For $40 or $50 -- or $250? Only if you're in bad need of an adrenalin fix.